Tobruk or Axis and Allies?

[MarioTani]

has someone ever played these WWII's war games?

I find Tobruk a good game, but I've never tried the other one...

to say it all I've used tobruk only in the first level (only tanks) and so I cannot make aproper confrontation....

...So here I am searching for suggestions^_^

[blinddog]

has someone ever played these WWII's war games?

I find Tobruk a good game, but I've never tried the other one...

to say it all I've used tobruk only in the first level (only tanks) and so I cannot make aproper confrontation....

...So here I am searching for suggestions^_^

The old Avalon Hill Tobruk was a fun game. Havent played it in many years.

I have not played Axis/Allies or its variants.

blinddog -the heathen

[Sutenhotep]

Played a lot of the Original Axis & Allies game, but not the "Europe" and "Pacific" variants.

It's not in depth like some of the war games, but still is a lot of fun. There's a couple of versions out on the computer, but I would recommend trying to find the "Iron Blitz" version of the computer game if you wanted to try it. It's the best adaptation of the board game.

[mr_peltast]

Tobruk is a tactical level game where as Axis and Allies is Strategic (unless you are referring to the Miniature game) level game. Hard to compare the two games. There is also Advanced Torbruk game system published by Critical Hit.

If you want to play tanks but not at the squad level detail of ASL (advanced squad leader) may I suggest platoon level games such as Panzerblitz: Hill of Death by Multiman publishing, Panzergrenadier series by Avalanche press, and World at War:Eisenbach gap by Lock'nLoad games.